Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bernard Golden's avatar

I had always heard Colonel Blimp used as shorthand for a kind of dim, blustery military fool. Then i saw the movie and realized the (actual?) character was brave, honorable, and far from dim. Great movie. And Roger Livesey gave a great performance.

Expand full comment
combatadj's avatar

Provocative title. One remembers what happened to MacArthur when he made the mistake of thinking he was setting American Strategy, the wisdom of his thinking notwithstanding. It is a lesson not lost on military officers even today.

Having completed Naval War College recently, I can tell you that the military has a very clear view of what strategy is and how it should be developed and implemented. What flag officers do with that knowledge once they become key decision-makers, the military universities cannot account for.

Many of the issues you address in regards to our Ways and Means (in a country where we can rarely agree on what the strategic Ends are) are concerns that keep all of us awake at night. In my 30+ years of DoD experience, I have never seen an environment where uncertainty and risk are so readily accepted and embraced, with mitigations for those risks clearly identified and pursued.

I was happy to see you ended your blog post with the assessment that we are, at the end of the day, a civilian-led military, as it should be. Democracies are poor at developing Grand Strategy - consider the number of inconsistencies between our current National Security Strategy and our National Defense Strategy. We may never get it right. But an engaged public voting for engaged leaders would go a long way towards getting it MORE right than our competitors through the entire DIME-FIL spectrum.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts